3/30 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[Krom]

A few odd notes from Siobahn. Then again, even at her worst, her personality carries her a long way. Plus, there was still a part of the song, even this week, which was still pretty awesome. She just needs practice. Practice, practice, practice. 'Cause this was a low point.

Shut up Ellen. I wish you knew more what you were talking about. You make Kara sound relevant. Which is hard to do.

She might be at risk this one week of any of them. I'd hate this to be a shock boot week.

[Unklescott]

TopCat (I think that's who it was) posted earlier in the spoiler thread

Keep them in that thread. Don't reveal them here. This is for real time spoilers only please.

[Unklescott]

Siobhan gets raked over the coals by the judges.

[xmaskat]

Good grief... why are the judges going on and on about her not-so-good performance? Shut up already.

[AsIs]

Awww, Siobahn looks like she is going to cry. She wasn't that bad. There were parts of the song that were pretty good. And I don't really like that song.

[canuckinchile]

Yeah, I hate the dragging on of it all by Ryan. Make the show shorter if you have to.

[Willowwisp]

Siobhan gets raked over the coals by the judges.

I think she needed it. She didn't listen to the judges last week about the "screaming".. and she was out of tune, and out of breath... and I think the judges know she is a major contender here... and she needed to hear the truth.. it wasn't great.

Maybe next week she will listen to the judges..

[SanJoseMom]

Yeah, I love Ellen, but am not enjoying her as a judge. Her humor seems so forced. At the risk of sounding shallow, her lighting and makeup people on her own show make her look really good (a la Oprah), but she looks older and painted on Idol.

[LalahLand]

Siobahn was straining. I wonder what happened...

[Krom]

Wow. A backstage walk o' dejection. They've never shown that before.