2/24 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[Unklescott]

They need to stop with all this Kara fawning crap all over him. Would they be doing this with Simon and one of the female contestants? I think not.

[I'm MEL]

Ooh, Ellen, "It was not fair." Too bad she wasn't around last year to reprimand Simon and whats-her-name when they were drawing on each other's faces and such.

[Krom]

If Simon or Randy treated a girl this way, there would be outrage and I am sickened by Kara's behaviour.

Anyway Casey was predictable and boring. Vocals were alright though.

Randy was encouraging it too. When they pulled the camera back you could clearly see that Randy was holding her arms up from behind her making her do that little side to side "Paula sway".

Of course that's typical of Randy--he's there as a goad half the time. It's not like he ever has anything genuinely useful to say (or do).

[KofferMum]

Kara is now OTT sleaze.

Yes, Kara needs to knock it off as it is becoming offensive to all.
Except to Casey, of course.
But that kind of 'endorsement' can hinder votes and backlash.

[TopCatDC]

Re: Sexy Casey

What am I missing? He's not that cute. I'd say he's fairly average looking. Maybe you have to be there. I'd say Joe and Tim have it all over Casey. Maybe Casey just has a "sexy" vibe.

[Fudatskee]

why do they need 4 judges? It's like a slow painful death....

[TeacherLady]

I LOVED Casey -- and I would have still loved that performance if he were ugly as a toad.

Now for Andrew.

[libgirl2]

I LOVED Casey -- and I would have still loved that performance if he were ugly as a toad.

Now for Andrew.

It helps that he is cute, but I agree.

[Broadway]

Re: Sexy Casey

What am I missing? He's not that cute. I'd say he's fairly average looking. Maybe you have to be there. I'd say Joe and Tim have it all over Casey. Maybe Casey just has a "sexy" vibe.

I'd add Lee to that as well. I don't find Casey overly good-looking, either. And his incisor teeth are huge. Distracting.

[TopCatDC]

why do they need 4 judges? It's like a slow painful death....

The judges are a trip to Disneyland compared to the contestants.

Andrew Garcia finishes the night. (whew!) He gives us Sugar We're Going Down.

And he's very good. Not as good as Casey, if you ask me.

Simon: Was looking forward to this, but you were disappointing. Good story, nice guy, and great recording voice. But you have to get better.
Kara: Straight Up bought you some time, but the song went off.
Randy: Weird arrangement.
Ellen: You were inside of yourself until you spotted your wife in the audience. You need to open up more.