2/23 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[Krom]

Paige Miles up first. Who IS this girl?

They completely didn't show her until near the end of Hollywood week (certainly not in auditions). Then they had her as part of some montage or something like that. And she was most memorable for frankly... lookin' a bit weird.

That was... a bit meh. Maybe its just the song.

[KofferMum]

That wasn't as good as the judges thought it was to me.

[xmaskat]

That wasn't as good as the judges thought it was to me.

I agree. I like the song, but not her version of it. Part of it could be I am so used to the song being sung by men.
I do not remember this girl at all from auditons or Hollywood week.

[TopCatDC]

Ashley Rodriguez next. Sings Happy.

I wish she hadn't mentioned Jordan Sparks, because she's good, but she isn't that good in the pure vocal department. She's a good stylist, though. But that first low part was poorly done.

Kara: Should take on a different kind of song.
Randy: Don't want to be compared to the big singers.
Ellen: Step out into a whole different vibe; take a risk.
Simon: Not contemporary; no originality.

[I'm MEL]

Oh no, I just realized that I didn't have my DVR set to record, so I've missed whatever has happened up to this point!!! That won't happen again!

[Krom]

Who the hell is a Jordin Sparks fan? I guess she's that ONE.

And this girl's performance is kind of a barrel of crap. I mean I guess I've heard worse... but it was. Again, maybe its a CRAP song.

[CupidGuest]

I don't like that performance.

[libgirl2]

That was bad!

[I'm MEL]

Ooh, maybe I tuned in too soon....

[StarryElf]

Ashley reminds me of someone, but I'm not sure who. Also, performance was meh.