2/23 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[WinkyD]

How to Get Booted: Verbalize Your Disagreement with Simon.

[Quemoni]

Hmmm Lacey that was disappointing. I didn't like this song at all. It was sort of slow and twangy but in a weird way.

Strange resonance to it...I felt like I should cry...like I was listening to bootlegged "Cold Miner's Daughter"

which I love by the way....

[libgirl2]

How to Get Booted: Verbalize Your Disagreement with Simon.

and pick a song you love but cannot sing!

[libgirl2]

Hmmm Lacey that was disappointing. I didn't like this song at all. It was sort of slow and twangy but in a weird way.

Strange resonance to it...I felt like I should cry...like I was listening to bootlegged "Cold Miner's Daughter"

which I love by the way....

can you sing CMD??

[CantinaBandFan]

I heard a spoiler about Siobhan's song choice....it could go really bad if she sings it.

[LalahLand]

Is it just me or is the style Lilly sang in totally overdone--it's already been done by Norah Jones, Chrisette Michelle, Erika Badu... the list goes on. She has a pretty voice though... but the style is old.

[libgirl2]

So far not a terribly impressive night.... a couple of good ones...

[AsIs]

Ryan: Why did you pick that song?
Lacey: "I just love that song."

Oh, Lacey. That's why you pick a song at a karaoke bar, not on American Idol.

Update: Ha ha! AsIs - two great minds think alike!

I knew I liked you!

[mom3]

Okay, if this is a year for the girls, we're not doing so well so far. What, 2 for 6 maybe?

I was thinking the same thing. Here's hoping the final girls redeem the group.

[MotherSister]

Okay, if this is a year for the girls, we're not doing so well so far. What, 2 for 6 maybe?

This happens every year. Whichever gender is supposed to be superior, they come out and bite it on the first live night. If I thought it was on purpose, I'd give AI some credit for being subversive.