2/16 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[TopCatDC]

NO, that's jermaine sellers

Hey - congrats pattycake92 on 1000 posts!

[RealityLovesMe]

Awww...I really liked Shelby. I was hoping she would make it. Maybe she'll come back next season. Or replace whichever Idol has a criminal record and gets booted...

Her audition wasn't that impressive. Maybe that's why. Janell Wheeler really did not deserve to make it.

[Krom]

Michael Lynche - IN

This year's Michael Sarver?

Ew. Why'd you put THAT thought in my head!

[RealityLovesMe]

Michael Lynche used to be signed to a rinky dink record label and he had some really interesting music. He's really different now (in a bad way). He's trying to be John Mayer and that just doesn't suit him. I'm not too thrilled he made it singing this style.

[TopCatDC]

Here's what I think we know after last night's (Tuesday) episode:

Top 24

• Michael Lynch
• Didi Benami
• Katelyn Epperly
• Casey James
• Aaron Kelly
• Lee Dwyze
• Todrick Hall

In the Running for Top 24, but Status Unknown

• Tim Urban
• Tyler Grady
• Andrew Garcia
• Michelle Delamore
• Haeley Vaughn
• Maddy Penrose
• Chris Golightly
• Lacey Brown
• John Park
• Angela Martin
• Alex Lambert
• Crystal Bowersox
• Siobhan Magnus
• Thaddeus Johnson
• Tori Kelly
• Lilly Scott
• Katy Stevens

Cut Before Top 24

• Shelby Dressler
• Jessica Furney

Eliminated in Room 2

• Kia Johnson
• Lloyd Thomas
• Mary Powers
• Hope Johnson
• Tisha Holland
• Jermaine Purifory
• Christian Spear

Who did I miss?

[I'm MEL]

Michael Lynche used to be signed to a rinky dink record label and he had some really interesting music. He's really different now (in a bad way). He's trying to be John Mayer and that just doesn't suit him. I'm not too thrilled he made it singing this style.

Did he actually have a record released? Have you heard it?

[libgirl2]

i concur!!! simon liked her, me too!!

I saw the same.... anyone think they might "bring her back" if someone has a record etc.... ??

[captain]

Shelby is good - but I don't see the "artist" inside that could take on all comers in the finals.

Did Simon just say "That was the wrong decision?"

I thought I heard the same thing.[/I]

[libgirl2]

I heard "wrong decision" too.

[cape]

I heard "wrong decision" too.

So did I!

Our house was sad to see Shelby go!

My DH likes Crystal Bowersox the best. I like her voice but she is in serious need of a makeover. If she looked like she had washed her hair - ever - it would be much easier to watch her. I know that is the style she is going for but I don't think it will be good for her to keep that look.