Kellie Pickler - Season 5

She already won American Idol--under the name Carrie Underwood. Yawn.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Broadway

This makes it sound like her ability to burp like a man is making her dreams come true. :lol

---

What Broadway? Isn't that every woman's dream:)

I really like her voice

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FireStorm

She already won American Idol--under the name Carrie Underwood. Yawn.

---

I think we should judge her on her own merit, I don't see any resemblence to Carrie Underwood (other than a country girl with blond hair). ??

She's one of my favs already. A really sweet girl. The look on her face when they told her she made it was one of disbelief.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Misty8723

I think we should judge her on her own merit, I don't see any resemblence to Carrie Underwood (other than a country girl with blond hair). ??

---

I meant I'm sick of the country singing blonde act, so boring, I can't be the only one. :kitty

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lex

I like Kellie a lot. Not the best singer, but I like her personality. She's not phoney at all.

---

See that's the thing. This is a singing competition, not a popularity contest or beauty pageant. I really don't like her voice, there were more talented, albeit less attractive singers that should have taken her place.

Nice girl and everything, but reminds me too much of Manjaw (marginal singing ability and all). I hope she doesn't make it to the top twelve.

I'm hoping she'll be in the top 12. I cannot see why
she wouldn't be.

She's a pretty girl with talent and can probably belt out some songs...I'm wondering if her nerves might be a problem...then again, she's use to performing...I like her and unless she just falls flat on her face, I expect her in the Top 12....