Carrie Underwood

[JonasGrumby]

How do you think she'd do if she sings a rock song...like "My Immortal", "Tourniquet" or "Bring Me To Life" by Evanescence? Wouldn't that be awesome if she could sing them.

[Slider]

"would" not "could" There's no question in my mind she has the voice to sing any song you throw at her extremely well.

[Slider]

I don't doubt it at all. This competition is Carrie's to lose.

[funkalicious]

After that performance I don't really like her anymore. Aloha has overtaken her in my mind!

[Kariann1]

If Carrie were to win, would she be allowed to use any of her band members?

She has the looks and the voice but I really believe they are looking for a GUY this time. I do believe she'll be right up there in the Top Twelve!

[razorbacker]

If Carrie were to win, would she be allowed to use any of her band members?

She has the looks and the voice but I really believe they are looking for a GUY this time. I do believe she'll be right up there in the Top Twelve!

Carrie & Bo both apparantely play multiple instruments. Wouldn't it be interesting for these two to get together after this competition & collaborate on something? I think the differences in their voices would make for a very interesting duet. I believe they will both do well no matter the outcome of this show, but I really believe Carrie has the making of a terrific cross over artist & can be popular in more than one genre.

[weathergirl91]

I LOVE Carrie. I think she has an amazing voice, but I agree that they are most likely looking for a guy this time. I also agree though, that I will be seeing her in the top 12. I just have a feeling.

[Kariann1]

I think Carrie will hit the Country scene big time! I thought she would have done well at Nashville Star, but they seem to prefer the gentlemen. At AI she has the opportunity to reach a bigger audience! Being in the Top Five would certainly help her career.

I need to hear more from some of the other gals before I can declare a favorite!

[IdolBud123]

Does anyone else consider her to be more of a pop singer rather than a country singer? I know I do, especially after her last performance.

[writergirl26]

Does anyone else consider her to be more of a pop singer rather than a country singer? I know I do, especially after her last performance.

I think Carrie prefers to sing country, but she has the voice to sing any genre she wants. As I stated earlier in this thread, country music has changed so much lately that many artists have cross-over appeal.