I see where you are coming from, but this is basically a Pop show, looking for the next Pop star. It is not a show looking for the next Rock Star, so why even have a rock week.Originally Posted by kitschcakes
One could argue that this isn't Disco Idol either. Though in comparission Disco and Pop are closer in genre to Pop and Rock.
I find that Disco and Latin and some of the best theme's on the show, and are closest to Pop.