Who did u think shouldnt have been there (in the top 20) and why?

[LucyHaleFan]

No offense to Tyler Foehr but i think people like Alex Catalani or Ciarra Farrow could have taken his place. He wasnt even that good. and his massive amounts of energy freaked me out.

[Dani321]

I was shocked neither Nelson twin made it. That takes Katelyn and Jordan out of the competition. I also remember a girl from NYC who sang reflection--I thought she was VERY good. She could've had Lauren's spot.

I don't remember a Ciarra--refresh my memory please.

[eatmorchiken]

Ciarra was the little girl Chicago who wore her hair up and sang I'm so excited. She was only 7 i think and she was a very good dancer, but not that good of a singer

[LovingMorganB]

AMANDA RITTWEGER. She sang "I Turn to You" at the New York auditions.

[trunks]

They all deserved it. I liked all 20.

[Cassandra]

I agree they all deserved it.

[Thunderstruck]

I posted this in another topic too, but it belongs here as well:
Remember, auditioning in front of JUST the judges is completely different than in front of millions. To compare the two is unfair.

[CanyonsSis]

kara and grace because they were just bad

[xoxkels06xox]

Lauren and Tyler shouldn't have. I think Alex and Amanda should have!

[Boredom]

As much as I have been the anti-Tyler person on the boards (usually) I think that all of them probably deserved it. People might have done well just for the judges, but they might have had a nervous break down in front of the cameras.