Who did u think shouldnt have been there (in the top 20) and why?

[ruebenalltheway]

i thought they all deserved to be there.

[aifan4life]

Personally, no offense to any AJ Melendez fans, but he wasn't as deserving as some.

[jeenyusgirl]

they were all good

[CanyonsSis]

who was amanda and what did she look like?

[kitten]

I think that they all deserved to be there. They are young and have worked hard. I think in Kara's case, she let nerves take over making her sound worse than she really is. Lauren-she's just young and hasn't learned how to control her voice and to open it up and not sing through her nose. In 10 years I bet if she gets proper training she could go out on broadway. Tyler-just had a song to sing that didn't show off any of his talent. It was a great song-for Sting. Grace-she just seemed really nervous as well, I like her voice.

[LovingMorganB]

who was amanda and what did she look like?

They only showed her once.. her mom siad that she could cry just talking about her because Amanda has brought her nothing but joy since the day she was born. She had long light brown hair and was very pretty. If you have the auditions on tape, she tried out in New York.

[hopelesscorky]

IMO Kara should have been replaced by amanda. Quinton should have been replaced by Kaci. Just my opinion the others i thought were deserving.

[poeticjustice]

It's not that I don't want the Thompson girls in the top twenty, (or the band), it's just that we will keep having to see their hairdresser mother.
I hope she doesn't shake those hips again!