Lucy, Chantel or BOTH?

[JuniorsFANatic]

I would also rather have niether in the group but if one has to be in I'd have to pick Chantel. I just don't like Lucy for some reason.. I was honestly surprised that both she even got into the top 10 especially since Chantel had already been voted in... their voices are waaaay too similar but Chantel looks better on stage and once again doesn't come across as "a 13 year old trying to sing like a 20 year old"

[cupcake33]

I think Lucy is more talented, but Chantel's voice and personality seem better suited to a group.

[~I Luv Canyon~]

totally lucy

[All My Luv 2 AJ]

at first I wanted Lucy but she is just to good to be in a group imo. I really want Lucy to be a solo artist. So I want Chantel to make it into the group just because she is made for a group and not a solo artist.

[CanyonsSis]

I think they'll both make it, but I hope only Lucy makes it.

[ChantelFan]

umm I like Chantel better

[aifan4life]

Since Chantel has a bigger fan base than the other contestants, I'd say she'll make it. Although, that doesn't necessarily mean she will. Lucy could surprise us and take a spot right there, and then again, both of them are extremely talented with rocky performances from time to time, so they could both very well make it!

[Clayalltheway49]

I think Chantel over Lucy. In the past when she sang "I'm Gonna Make You Love Me," she copied the way that Play remade it (play is a fairly new music group) She tried to copy them. I always thought Lucy was kinda cookie cutter. But she is in the group and there is nothing I can do about it. *shrugs shoulders*

[CanyonsSis]

I was actually surprised how much it DIDN'T sound like the Play version.

[LucyHale]

Both!!!